Why Is She Being Blamed for Her Cancer?

At 60, Maria — not her real name - thought she had done everything right. She exercised. Ate well. Meditated.

She quit smoking at 28 — more than 30 years ago. So, when she was diagnosed with lung cancer, she was shocked, and she expected others to be as well. She didn’t expect shame.

It came in the form of quiet questions from doctors and colleagues — Did you smoke? For how long?

People with lung cancer need to fight not just cancer, but judgment. Stigma is the hidden burden of lung cancer. Many people see it as self-inflicted, a perception shaped by decades of public health messaging. But that assumption is wrong and harmful.

Research shows that patients experience both external stigma — judgment from others — and internal stigma, including guilt, regret, and self-blame. These feelings persist even in people like Maria, who quit decades ago, and even among those who never smoked at all.

In fact, about 1 in 5 lung cancer cases occur in people with no smoking history, particularly among women. Yet the narrative of blame remains stubbornly fixed.

And it matters. People who feel judged are more likely to delay care. More likely to hide their diagnosis. More likely to struggle with anxiety, depression, and isolation.

Stigma doesn’t just follow cancer. It shapes outcomes.

And it comes from everywhere — public messaging, family, even the healthcare system. Society’s anti-smoking campaigns, while lifesaving, have sometimes reinforced the idea that lung cancer reflects personal failure. We would never ask a breast cancer patient what they did to deserve their illness. But lung cancer patients hear that question all the time.

Maria remembers deciding not to tell a colleague about her diagnosis. “I didn’t want to see that look,” she said.

That “look” isolates. It silences. It turns illness into judgment. Studies suggest that even many healthcare providers view lung cancer patients as more responsible for their illness than those with other cancers.

But Maria did smoke? Doesn’t that matter?

Yes, smoking increases risk. But risk isn’t the same as blame. Most people who began smoking did so when they were young, in the face of an industry designed to make starting smoking easy and quitting difficult. Nicotine is not just a choice — it is an addiction.

We don’t deny care to someone with heart disease because they ate steak, or to a driver because they weren’t wearing a seatbelt. Illness is not a moral test. If anything, those who have struggled with addiction deserve more compassion, not less.

So, we need to change the conversation. Lung cancer has many causes, including environment, genetics, and, yes, sometimes smoking. But none of these erase a person’s right to care and dignity.

Maria quit smoking more than 30 years ago. She should not still be paying for it.

It’s time we stop asking, “What did you do?” And start asking, “How can we help?”

— Dr. Michael Wilkes with a Second Opinion

The latest on Question Everything with Brian Reed: How a tiny newsroom helped bring down Hungary’s authoritarian leader.