Dear DnA readers,
I hope you are doing well.
Angelenos may be sad about the Southland (see "Not Digging," below), but there is reason to be cheerful if you love museums.
Hot off the completion of the David Geffen Galleries at LACMA, the Lucas Museum of Narrative Art opens its doors! It held its press preview this week, and opens to the public on September 22nd. Like the Geffen Galleries, the LMNA plays with expectations both in architecture and curation.
And this one delivers the wide-eyed wonderment of the cinematic creations of the museum's cofounder George Lucas: a five-story, 300,000-square-foot, fluid structure, wrapped in a sinewy, rippling and robot-buffed skin of over 1,500 customized gray-white panels, designed by the architect Ma Yansong of MAD, with Stantec. It sits within a 13-acre campus, with scenic gardens extending from ground level to the roof, designed by Mia Lehrer of Studio-MLA. And it displays a portion of Lucas's collection of some 40,000 pieces of "narrative" art. The goal for George Lucas, said his wife and museum cofounder Mellody Hobson, was "a building so unique that eight-year-olds and 80-year-olds would equally want to come inside." There is much to say about it, but in brief, here are a few notes:
Central plaza and oculus at Lucas Museum. Photo by Hufton+Crow
Origins
The museum has been some 17 years in the making, dating from when Lucas first offered it to Presidio Park in San Francisco. It went next to Hobson’s hometown of Chicago, but there Yansong’s 2014 competition-winning design was thwarted by a lawsuit from a group of opponents. Then San Francisco came back in play, but so did Los Angeles. Mayor Eric Garcetti pushed for it to be built on an empty parking lot at the west end of Exposition Park. In 2017, LA garnered the project, and, after a lengthy and complex construction process, here it is. As Lucas told the crowd at the press preview Wednesday, "This has been a long haul... between getting kicked out of cities and trying to get this built... but I'm a contrarian. I'm fascinated by doing things that people say can't be done."
Robert Colescott, George Washington Carver Crossing the Delaware: Page from an American History Textbook, 1975
What is Narrative Art?
Everything about this museum is driven by the notion of “narrative art.” This term seems to have entered the lexicon in the 1950s and '60s when the fine art world favored Abstract Expressionism, then Conceptual and Minimalist art. It was used – often dismissively – to refer to paintings and sculpture that told visual stories about people, also known as representational or figurative art or realism. By way of musical analogy, this was like suggesting that minimalist composer John Cage’s 4′33″ of silence was artistically superior to Dolly Parton’s Jolene.
Representations of family. Photo by Frances Anderton
Narrative art was having a heyday last century with the explosion of printed stories — children’s books, comic books, pulp fiction novels, advertising, popular magazines and of course, the movies. George Lucas grew up loving this popular visual culture, from Beatrix Potter’s illustrations of Peter Rabbit and friends through Norman Rockwell’s wry paintings of small-town America and Flash Gordon comic strips to the detailed worldbuilding by concept artists Lucas worked with.
He saw in these beautifully rendered illusory worlds the construction of meaning and myths that bind peoples, and set about collecting this kind of art and creating it. At the museum you’ll find a small portion of his huge holdings, curated by Lucas into themes such as childhood, love and family, above. You will also find Star Wars memorabilia: costumes, set paintings and props like NabooStarfighter, below.
Photo by Frances Anderton
What about the building and the gardens?
The building by Chinese architect Ma Yansong is intended as a piece of narrative architecture, which is typically understood as architecture that is symbolic or evocative of feeling and associations. That can take the form of a period revival or thematic styles — of which we have many in LA – but the Lucas Museum is not in an obvious style. It is, however, intended to evoke emotion and the feeling of being on a journey.
The soaring north lobby. Photo by Hufton+Crow
Even though it's hard not to look at the building and think "space ship," the architect likens his long, fluid building to both a cloud and the shade-giving tree. He also points out that the experience is meant to be a journey -- one that starts in a large plaza area lit by an oculus, pulling the eye skyward, and taking the visitor through multiple spatial experiences -- among them a soaring lobby, biomorphic store and cafeteria, elevators like interstellar transit which zoom up to the 4th floor galleries. All are carefully crafted subworlds within Ma's overarching concept.
Garden viewed from 4th floor. Photo by Frances Anderton
The garden extends the narrative theme, though here the story is one of a journey through the “California transept.” "We looked to California's mountains, foothills, valleys, mesas, canyons, and meadows, and some streams and rivers, and to the way topography, planting, and light can change the feeling of a place as you move through it. There is no single route through the gardens. Paths climb, descend, cross bridges, and embrace sculptures," said Lehrer.
All of this is realized with the stagecraft of the cofounder. Expanses of lawn and thousands of plants and trees flourish over a topography of cleverly concealed Geofoam blocks. The building, both futuristic and organic, was achievable thanks to today’s advanced digital tools, and a highly complex structure, realized by teams of skilled fabricators. But Ma says he and Lucas wanted to create effect, and intentionally tried "to hide all these architectural details" and the structure of the bridge-like steel structure, with its very large span, which "is so amazing. It's so beautiful."
Artoo and Threepio beside Ralph McQuarrie's production painting for Star Wars Episode IV: A New Hope (Artoo and Threepio leave the pod in the desert), January 31, 1975. Photo by Frances Anderton
The building is a wow, and much of the collection a delight, and intriguing in how it blithely ignores art world conventions. Rockwell, Robert Crumb, Picasso, N.C. Wyeth, Kara Walker, Frank Frazetta, Judith F. Baca, and numerous other talents from commercial and "fine" art realms coexist in this museum. There are original artworks and reproductions, sentimental and critical portrayals of American society, film characters and human archetypes. Botero's Maternity poses in the garden close by Princess Leia Frees Herself from Jabba the Hutt. There is minimal wall text (as at the new LACMA building) contextualizing all this. We will see how this very personal collection and curation will play with audiences. But it seems like a natural fit for Los Angeles, capital of storytelling.
Now, if only this level of love and ambition could be applied to improving L.A.'s public realm!
Read much more soon about the architecture and construction in a book I'm working on for the Lucas Museum. And hear from Ma Yansong himself when he speaks at USC, Bovard Auditorium, 6:00–8:00 PM, on the evening of the museum's opening day, September 22nd. Click here to RSVP.